• Mtayleb | Zahle
  • Mon - Fri : 8.00 - 4.00 Sat : 9.00 - 2.00
  • Admin
  • 22  May  2024

Nutritional Comparison of Animal and Plant-Based Milks: A Comprehensive Review

The consumption of milk from various sources has become increasingly diverse, ranging from traditional animal-based milks to various plant-based alternatives. This review aims to compare the nutritional profiles of animal milks (cow, sheep, and goat) with ten popular plant-based alternatives: almond, soy, coconut, rice, oat, cashew, hemp, flax, macadamia, and pea milk, highlighting the key differences and health implications.

 

Nutritional Profiles:

1. Animal Milk:

   - Cow's Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Cow's milk is a rich source of high-quality protein, providing approximately 8 grams per cup. It also contains significant amounts of fat (8 grams in whole milk) and carbohydrates (12 grams, primarily lactose).
  • Micronutrients: It is naturally high in calcium (300 mg per cup), vitamin D (when fortified), vitamin B12, and phosphorus. Cow's milk is also a good source of riboflavin (vitamin B2) and iodine.
  • Health Implications: Regular consumption of cow's milk can support bone health due to its high calcium and vitamin D content, and it is a reliable source of complete protein.

 

   - Sheep's Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Sheep's milk is higher in protein (14.7 grams per cup) and fat (17 grams per cup) compared to cow's milk.
  • Micronutrients: It contains more calcium (473 mg per cup) and vitamin B12 than cow's milk, and is also rich in zinc and B vitamins.
  • Health Implications: The higher protein and fat content can be beneficial for individuals needing more calories and nutrients. It may also be easier to digest for some people due to different fat structures.

 

   - Goat's Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Goat's milk provides about 9 grams of protein and 10 grams of fat per cup, with a similar carbohydrate content to cow's milk.
  • Micronutrients: It is rich in calcium (327 mg per cup), potassium, and vitamin A, and has slightly lower lactose levels.
  • Health Implications: Goat's milk is often easier to digest for people with lactose intolerance or cow's milk protein allergy due to its different protein and fat composition.

 

2. Plant-Based Milks:

   - Almond Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Almond milk is low in calories (30-50 calories per cup) and protein (1 gram per cup), with a higher fat content (2.5 grams) and low carbohydrate levels (1-2 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Often fortified with calcium and vitamin D, matching cow's milk in these nutrients. Almond milk also provides vitamin E, an antioxidant.
  • Health Implications: Almond milk is a good alternative for those who are lactose intolerant or have dairy allergies, but its low protein content may require supplementation from other dietary sources.

 

   - Soy Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Soy milk closely resembles cow's milk in protein content (7-8 grams per cup), with moderate fat (4 grams) and carbohydrates (4 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Often fortified with calcium, vitamin D, and B vitamins, soy milk also contains isoflavones, which have been associated with various health benefits.
  • Health Implications: As a nutritionally comparable alternative to cow's milk, soy milk is suitable for those seeking plant-based protein sources and may offer additional benefits due to its isoflavone content.

 

   - Coconut Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Coconut milk is higher in fat (5 grams per cup), primarily saturated fat, and low in protein (less than 1 gram) and carbohydrates (2 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Typically fortified with calcium and vitamin D, it also contains medium-chain triglycerides (MCTs), which are beneficial for energy metabolism.
  • Health Implications: While it is a flavorful alternative, coconut milk's high saturated fat content may be a concern for cardiovascular health if consumed in large amounts. It is not a significant source of protein.

 

   - Rice Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Rice milk is low in protein (less than 1 gram per cup) and higher in carbohydrates (22 grams per cup), with a low-fat content (2 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Often fortified with calcium, vitamin D, and B vitamins. It is naturally low in allergens, making it suitable for people with multiple food allergies.
  • Health Implications: Rice milk is a good alternative for those with soy, nut, or dairy allergies, but its low protein content and high glycemic index may not be suitable for everyone.

 

   - Oat Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Oat milk provides about 3 grams of protein and 2.5 grams of fat per cup, with higher carbohydrate content (16 grams).
  • Micronutrients: It is often fortified with calcium, vitamin D, and B vitamins, and is a good source of dietary fiber.
  • Health Implications: Oat milk's fiber content can be beneficial for digestive health. It is a suitable alternative for those with nut and dairy allergies, although its protein content is lower than cow's milk.

 

   - Cashew Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Cashew milk is low in calories (25-50 calories per cup) and protein (less than 1 gram), with a moderate fat content (2-4 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Often fortified with calcium, vitamin D, and B vitamins. It also contains healthy monounsaturated fats.
  • Health Implications: Cashew milk is a creamy alternative suitable for those with soy and dairy allergies, though its low protein content may require supplementation from other sources.

 

   - Hemp Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Hemp milk provides about 2-3 grams of protein and 4-5 grams of fat per cup, with low carbohydrate content (1-2 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Rich in omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, often fortified with calcium and vitamin D.
  • Health Implications: Hemp milk is a good source of essential fatty acids, beneficial for heart health, and suitable for those with soy, nut, and dairy allergies.

 

   - Flax Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Flax milk is low in calories (25-50 calories per cup) and protein (less than 1 gram), with moderate fat content (2-3 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Rich in alpha-linolenic acid (ALA), a type of omega-3 fatty acid, often fortified with calcium and vitamin D.
  • Health Implications: Flax milk is a good source of plant-based omega-3s, supporting cardiovascular health, though its low protein content may require supplementation from other sources.

 

   - Macadamia Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Macadamia milk is low in calories (50-70 calories per cup) and protein (1 gram), with higher fat content (4-5 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Often fortified with calcium and vitamin D, it contains healthy monounsaturated fats.
  • Health Implications: Macadamia milk is a creamy, flavorful alternative rich in heart-healthy fats, suitable for those with soy and dairy allergies, though its low protein content may require supplementation from other sources.

 

   - Pea Milk:

  • Macronutrients: Pea milk is higher in protein (7-8 grams per cup) compared to other plant-based milks, with moderate fat (4-5 grams) and carbohydrate content (8 grams).
  • Micronutrients: Often fortified with calcium, vitamin D, and B vitamins, and contains a balanced profile of essential amino acids.
  • Health Implications: Pea milk is a nutritionally rich alternative, particularly for those seeking a high-protein plant-based option.

 

Comparison and Conclusion:

  • Protein Content: Cow's milk, sheep's milk, goat's milk, soy milk, and pea milk are superior sources of protein compared to other plant-based milks like almond, coconut, rice, oat, cashew, hemp, flax, and macadamia milk.
  • Calcium and Vitamin D: Fortification in plant-based milks can provide comparable levels to cow's milk, but natural sources like sheep's milk have higher calcium content.
  • Fat Content: Coconut milk is high in saturated fats, while almond, rice, and flax milk have healthier fat profiles. Cow's milk, goat's milk, and macadamia milk offer balanced options, with variations like low-fat or skim versions.
  • Special Nutrients: Soy milk offers isoflavones, almond milk provides vitamin E, coconut milk contains MCTs, oat milk offers dietary fiber, hemp and flax milks are rich in omega-3 fatty acids, and macadamia milk provides heart-healthy fats, each with unique health benefits.

 

In summary, the choice between animal and plant-based milks depends on individual nutritional needs, dietary restrictions, and health goals. While cow's milk offers a comprehensive nutrient profile, fortified plant-based milks and other animal milks like goat and sheep can serve as effective alternatives, each contributing unique benefits to a balanced diet.

 

 References:

1. U.S. Department of Agriculture. (2021). "FoodData Central." Retrieved from [USDA FoodData Central] (https://fdc.nal.usda.gov/)

2. Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. (2020). "Calcium and Milk: What's Best for Your Bones and Health?" Retrieved from [Harvard Nutrition Source](https://www.hsph.harvard.edu/nutritionsource/calcium/)

3. Vanga, S. K., & Raghavan, V. (2018). "How well do plant based alternatives fare nutritionally compared to cow’s milk?" Journal of Food Science and Technology, 55(1), 10-20.

4. National Institutes of Health. (2016). "Soy." Retrieved from [NIH Office of Dietary Supplements](https://ods.od.nih.gov/factsheets/Soy-HealthProfessional/)

5. Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations. (2013). "Milk and Dairy Products in Human Nutrition." Retrieved from [FAO](http://www.fao.org/3/i3396e/i3396e.pdf)

6. Institute of Medicine. (2011). "Dietary Reference Intakes for Calcium and Vitamin D." Retrieved from [National Academies Press](https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK56070/)

7. Haug, A., Høstmark, A. T., & Harstad, O. M. (2007). "Bovine milk in human nutrition–a review." Lipids in Health and Disease, 6, 25.

8. Tziboula-Clarke, A. (2003). "Goat milk." In: Roginski, H., Fuquay, J. W., & Fox, P. F. (Eds.), Encyclopedia of Dairy Sciences. Academic Press, 1270-1275.

9. Lu, L., et al. (2016). "Nutritional composition comparison between dairy products and plant-based alternatives." Journal of Food Science, 81(10), R2369-R2376.

10. Craig, W. J. (2009). "Health effects of vegan diets." The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 89(5), 1627S-1633S.

11. Messina, V. (2016). "Nutritional and health benefits of dried beans." The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, 100(suppl 1), 437S-442S.

12. Alzate, A., & Castro-González, M. I. (2020). "Nutritional and health benefits of soy milk in comparison with cow milk: An overview." Food Reviews International, 36(1), 72-82.

13. Munekata, P. E., et al. (2021). "Nutritional, functional, and health benefits of plant-based dairy substitutes." Foods, 10(11), 2547.

14. Jung, S., & Messina, M. J. (2019). "Soy milk and the risk of breast cancer recurrence: A review of the literature." Journal of Human Nutrition and Dietetics, 32(3), 310-321.

15. Sethi, S., Tyagi, S. K., & Anurag, R. K. (2016). "Plant-based milk alternatives: An emerging segment of functional beverages." Critical Reviews in Food Science and Nutrition, 56(3), 342-349.

16. Brouwer-Brolsma, E. M., & de Vries, J. H. (2019). "Nutritional composition and health benefits of coconut and its products." Nutrients, 11(5), 1253.

17. McCarthy, K. S., Parker, M., Ameerally, A., Drake, S. L., & Drake, M. A. (2017). "Drivers of choice for fluid milk versus plant-based alternatives: What are consumer perceptions of fluid milk?" Journal of Dairy Science, 100(8), 6125-6138.

18. Gibson, R. S., Heath, A. L. M. (2011). "Dietary zinc and health outcomes: a review of the evidence." Food and Nutrition Bulletin, 32(1), 31-59.